Scenarios › Consulting

Centralized vs. Decentralized: Business Case for a Function

Centralizzato vs decentralizzato: business case per funzione · Consulting · Advanced · 250 XP

Each of the group's 8 divisions has its own HR function, resulting in inconsistent practices and duplication of effort. Corporate wants to centralize but the divisions resist loss of autonomy. The user must build a rigorous business case that models the cost and quality impact of three models: fully centralized, fully decentralized, and a shared services hybrid, with a clear recommendation.

Write the prompt you would give any AI (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot) to solve this real workplace scenario. Grace evaluates it in seconds across 7 dimensions: Role, Context, Objective, Constraints, Format, Audience, Efficiency: with a 0-100 score and coaching feedback. Your first 5 evaluations each day are free.

Train on this scenario →

Part of these learning paths

• Organizational Transformation

Frequently asked questions

What is the "Centralized vs. Decentralized: Business Case for a Function" scenario on Grace?

Each of the group's 8 divisions has its own HR function, resulting in inconsistent practices and duplication of effort. It is an advanced-level Consulting training scenario: you write the prompt you would give an AI to handle this situation, and Grace scores it from 0 to 100 with coaching feedback.

Who is "Centralized vs. Decentralized: Business Case for a Function" for?

It is designed for Consulting professionals and anyone who wants to handle this kind of situation with AI. The advanced difficulty makes it a solid test for experienced prompt writers.

Is this scenario part of a learning path?

Yes: it appears in "Organizational Transformation", structured paths that take you from first prompt to certification.

What should a strong prompt for this scenario include?

Assign the AI a precise role, give the key facts of the situation, state a verifiable objective, declare constraints (length, tone, what to avoid), and ask for the exact output format you need. Grace scores each of these elements separately.

Can I retry "Centralized vs. Decentralized: Business Case for a Function" to improve my score?

Yes. Read the coaching feedback, strengthen the weak dimensions and submit again: your best score is what counts. When you clear it, 8 related Consulting scenarios are waiting.

Related Consulting scenarios

• Issue Tree for Revenue Decline
• Key Findings Synthesis for Partner Readout
• Executive Summary for the Client CEO
• Hypothesis Tree for an Operational Problem
• Project Kick-Off Meeting with Client C-Suite
• Interim Readout: Partial Results to the Board
• Final Recommendation Using the Pyramid Principle
• 8-Week Workplan for a Strategy Engagement

📱 Download the Android app (beta) iOS coming soon

Say what you mean. Get what you need.

Grace Certified, the AI coach that trains and certifies your prompt engineering, by Agora Intelligence.